which one was more scathing. my vote is "Malcom X" tho "Smackdown" had some harsh and brutely honest shit. i like both D12 and Royce but D12 embarrassed the hell outta royce when this came out.
for instance:

"We ain't Royce muthafucka we don't speak in vain
we don't act like we street, we don't not say names
we don't ask Em to put us in the door to get a deal
and turn our back on him when he need his boys for real *echoes*
you got dropped by everybody i know
Goon Sqwad, AWOL, and a couple of hoes SO *echoes*"-Denaun aka Kon Artist

"that's neither here nor there dawg
his first video was shot up in NY yall
is this nigga the king of detroit
or the king of gettin his ass whipped and left by his boys"-Denaun aka Kon Artist

"(I heard his crew was hot) is you serious dawg?
D-Elite? I ain't even gonna speak on yall
yall ain't worth it, half of your boys wear turbans
and Cha Cha's a toss up nigga, keep on perpin
I wanna see that lil nigga Tre one up
I fight him with one arm, tell Peter put the gun up"-Denaun aka Kon Artist

"yo em just got me a deal
i can eat right now
I ain't seen D12 ass around
That's Ryan Montgomery
thinkin out loud
with rhinestones in his doo rag
you tough dawg WOW"-Denaun aka Kon Artist

"so what if your father taught you how to box(get him!)
you didn't say that shit when Goon Sqwad hit the spot
{nigga left yo bitch nigga} D-Elite yall niggas ain't tough guys
X-Guv i beat yo ass with some bean pies{you know it, I know it}
so what if Journalist is your cousin?
who gives a fuck? bitch Mountain Climbaz Dirty Dozen{WHAT?}
or Runyan Ave will put 2 in your face(BOW!)
quick to catch a case don't make me have to run up in sudden place
is it our fault you a fake LL?
D12{D12!} the reason your lil record won't sell{7 thousand copies nigga}"-Bizarre and Swifty in Paranthese


even tho royce never got whooped but instead he and proof when they were cool tore up the club and beat the shit outta alot of niggaz. and bizarre cant talk cuz my brother went to there high school and saw when royce tore his ass in a freestyle competition.

now

v.s.

just a couple standout lines showin that everybody got some of the heat. obviously royce redeemed himself and ripped D12 a new one.

Proof:
"And I don't like Proof punk-ass, he think he tough
He keep thirty niggaz with him, cause he weak as fuck!
I ever catch you by yourself, I'ma fuck you up
Snatch your little cheap-ass chain and piece you up
You better hope you and the white boy keep in touch
And be a good little hype man, or your lease is up
Since Slim signed 50, I don't see your teeth as much
That's good, cause you got a grill like a fuckin truck!
DAMN HOMIE, it's history, over, hang it up
Go somewhere and hang up some 50 posters, PUNK"-Royce Da 5'9"

Bizarre:
"You, BITCH, Bizarre you a fat stutterin fuck
You a joke, I choke whoever buttered you up
I've been ridin by your house, you don't come out too much
You hidin, when I find you I'ma snatch you out of that truck
and tie your fat stankin ass to your couch and just
FEED YOU, you already look like you about to bust
Nigga you can run or hide; I'll be on your porch
with a cheeseburger tryin to lure you outside!
'Cause he's in it, Bizarre say G-g-g-g-g-g-unit
I bet you throw some extra "g's" in it
Just like a stutterin' fool can't reach intelligence
He sweats when he raps, cuz he got a speach impediment
You, BITCH, Porky's pig and Porky's tomb
About to dig his own grave with a fork and spoon"-Royce Da 5'9"

Denaun and Swifty:
"You, BITCH, Denaun and Swifty please
Give it in, both y'all be wreckin' 50's lease"-Royce Da 5'9"

"But you niggaz is WACK; Denaun I'ma stab you
So many times, I'ma feel bad when you collapse!
You niggaz is so BITCH you make me sick to my stomach
Every beat that you ever made sound like it was missin' somethin'
Timbaland lookin' ass, nigga, my style is realer
What producer you ever know only good for album filler"-Tre Little

Kuniva:
"What do I know, that other nigga y'all got in your group
I don't even know his name, but he can shovel my snow"-Royce Da 5'9"

Eminem:
"I just wish Eminem would stop tellin' everybody he ain't speakin' to me
Like I'm one of his hoes or somethin'
How 'bout this, I ain't speakin to you, chump
And I'ma keep pickin on your weak ass crew"-Royce Da 5'9"

"Quicker than quick shit, y'all ain't felt the half
Quicker than Eminem can pinch Elton's ass"-Royce Da 5'9"

"FUCK you and your commercial appeal
I turn yo' head into blue 'n yellow Purple Hills
I bet you whatever that nobody beats my family
Eminem, Nelly said that he'll eat you like candy
What did you do, got on the phone and called him up
You don't wanna talk to Royce, but you talk to us
You, BITCH, yo' crew some local hoes
I hit you harder than that white girl that broke your nose
You and Royce can squash this with one talk
Step around from your security and talk to that man
I understand you backin' yo' crew, but this my brother
Anythin' that happen to him, somethin' gonna happen to you
And I don't give a fuck for that, nigga, I'll do life
I advise you to stop; yo' money don't buy you stripes
Only thing that money brings is fake niggaz and problems
Followed by niggaz who hate fake niggaz and rob 'em"-Tre Little

ya'll be the judges

Em made a diss song to Nelly called Detroit Grammar. Nelly called Em. Royce's diss wasn't that good, all he does is talk about 50 Cent

how many times does he diss 50 on this track man. o now i forgot u ride shady/aftermath dick. that eplains eveything

royce was throwin punches at everyone and i respect him for that... i voted for him because D12 has turned into a commercialized P O S same as eminem

son Royce decapitated 7 emcees and a singer in 1 diss track

Been liked Malcolm X for awhile.

ya i was wonderin why this was put up today.. this beef has been around for a while

i know but alot niggaz sayin D12 ripped royce and shit and i wanted to get opinions.

haha people have to ignore jay#1 post. He is a shady/aftermath dickrider so all of his post is just irrelevant.

Man i love that cheeseburger line.

i know.. thats like the 4th post ive seen since ive been here that had so much stupidity in it so i take it hes the forum idiot?

I haven't heard these tracks. I gotta listen to it

All Royce does is complain how 50 was signed and he wasn't

son..no comment

^^Better be no comment

Lol...............

wow a new breezy. she gone be pissed at u

IMO, i didn't like either diss track. I was looking for some serious personal punchlines, not some corny lines to laugh at and tell friends to. I also didn't like all of the "this is what we/I do and this is what we're/I'm going to do" parts.

Now, maybe a second round could be worth listening to. But like I said, it was, in my opinion, a weak battle.

yo i like royce and d12...and royce had some good disses to bizarre but he kinda repeated himself throughout the 3 songs he released...malcom x was basically a summary of all of them. and royce didn't rhyme that good in the diss tracks, don't know why...and smackdown is more catchy with the whole "D Twizee" and all

vote- Smack Down

^you think that because you are a herb. L-)

bitch ass fag. go fuck a rhino you punk asshole.