View Full Version : SIXSHOT vs. SC.RAMBO


ramb
04-15-2006, 12:49 AM
size=free
animation=free
due=asap

SixShot
04-18-2006, 04:20 PM
heres mine... Vectored Eminem poster in rememberance to proof... Just think it fitted nicely. The vector took me ages to do... Ill post before and after pics in the Showoff area soon. If you want it ill think about hooking you up with it if you PM me nicely

http://img143.imageshack.us/img143/8149/emvector2tf.jpg

waiting on you

ramb
04-18-2006, 11:44 PM
http://img83.imageshack.us/img83/2816/scrambobattlesigtrans1238uw.gif

there man let the voting begin

Aero
04-19-2006, 09:32 PM
To me these are two totally different gfx so I'll rate them on how good they are individually.. The 1st one I'm not too sure I like how there's a cartoon of Em and then a real pic of proof in the background. Also I don't like the triangle shaped outline on Em. The text atop is blurry don't know if intentional or not. The blending is okay..

The 2nd one by rambo I don't like the red splattered across it. Looks generic, loses the feel. I like the text. The lighting is a good addition but seems random here.

Overrall I vote for Rambo b/c it was put together a little nicer...

Accept or decline my vote I don't care nukkas!

Adam™
04-19-2006, 09:37 PM
lmao whats funny is how scrambo has origional style on his sig when every1 else has that exact same style lol...

three6mafia#1
04-19-2006, 09:43 PM
Rambo: i liked the animation but the red really messes it up.I also liked the blood, but once again, the red...

Sixshot's was pretty nice.i liked the proof idea, and the text.I liked the animation, but the fading on proof throws it off

i vote for rambo

ramb
04-19-2006, 10:09 PM
2-0 uppin for the ko

Wreckin Eyez
04-21-2006, 06:17 PM
2-1

Uppin for votes.

*Killuminati*
04-21-2006, 10:11 PM
I would vote, both were nice pieces no doubt....but both are completely different, and I can't judge.

If there we guidelines or rules then it would be different, but I found this too hard to vote/judge......

SixShot
04-22-2006, 02:45 PM
Use the guidelines, Its classed as a vote if you use them or if you dont use them.... Please vote, I think your vote would be unbiased and would be fair...

*Killuminati*
04-23-2006, 08:34 PM
Ok then Imma vote rambo on this one, although sixes was original and the b/g was ill as fuck, all round it didn't fit IMO, rambo's fitted together nicely although the brushing is kinda wack.....

Six - seriously not feeling the jagged edge around em......

Vote: Rambo.....

ramb
04-23-2006, 11:32 PM
ok
3-1
uppin for more votes i guess lol
this is so dumb
i ko'd him already but whatever

Wreckin Eyez
04-24-2006, 01:33 AM
^^Shuttup... I could just disqualify everybody's votes including my own because nobody used the assigned voting format.

Alright, I'm going to allow the above votes. Mainly because I didn't use the format either.

But from now on, for a vote to count ON ANY BATTLE, it must be using the format assigned in the Voting Rules thread.

So Rambo, shuttup. Because all of your votes broke a bunch of the voting rules. Six' only broke one, not using the format.

Wreckin Eyez
04-24-2006, 01:42 AM
I deleted my vote, and shall now vote properly.

Design: Tie, both concepts sucked.
Effort: SixShot, not that hard to tell which put more into it
Creativity: SixShot, I've seen plenty of Rambos style by plenty of people.
Text: SixShot, simply better
Blending: Tie... Not one blending step taken in this entire battle. But hell, at least nobody feathered their render and called it blending.
Image cutting: Tie, couldn't really decide.
Brushing: Rambo, I didn't really see much in Six' unless they were enhancement brushes.
Background: Tie, both sucked.

I didn't really like either drop.

Rambo - Text is horrid, doesn't go with the piece at all. Sloppy, no aim, brushing. Background is boring, blending on the render is horrible. I, honestly, cannot find one good thing about this piece.

SixShot - Yours isn't much better, but I do have to give you the creativity front. The toon of Em needs more shadowing too it. Background is wierd and out of place. Text isn't bad, but it's not that good either.

Overall my vote goes to Six. His piece did seem better thought out and it's obvious he put more effort into it. Where Rambos looks like he just closed his eyes with the brush tool in hand.

Vote: SixShot

^^That's how every vote shall go from this point on.