This is the biggest question out. Who do you think is better. Even though Kobe has 3 rings, T-Mac is still one of the best players out. Some haters say Shaq won the Rings and not Kobe. But think, Shaq never won any rings without Kobe. Then when Kobe comes along, they start winning. **think bout that**. Anyway, T-Mac is leadin in the scoring, but 2nd place for Kobe is still good. But, winning is the biggest part in the game, so I vote Kobe better. But T-Mac is just behind him by a millapoint.

T-Mac is better than Kobe. Kobe was starring but know its T Time

Easily Tracy McGrady, I mean look at what he's doin in Orlando, he has barely no role players at all (Drew Gooden) and he doesnt take as many shots as Kobe does per game.

TMAC is tha shit yo. he is taking oour crap ass team of orlando with a buncha nobodies(except armstorng and gooden ) and making them make the playoffs. Kobe has shaq and a few other good role players. T mac has taken a worse team and made em as good if not better thne the lakers.TMAC is better and will be forever.

Nah, you can't say that. Just cuz Kobe has good players on his team doesn't mean he can't take his team to the playoffs if Shaq wasn't on it. You don't know what Kobe would do if he was in T-Mac's position. Kobe isn't any less of a player cuz his team is more balanced than the magics.

T-MAc is better. Not by far, but easily acknowledge. 60% of the damn time anyways he scores 39 and sits out the fourth quarter

kobe's a legend!! there's nobody betta then him!!! Period!

Kobe has tha best skill in the NBA. Kobe has defense where is Magrady with first team defensively. get off his n-u-t-zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Kobe al the way... even tho it is a tough challenge, both got skill both Kobe is just top-class

K-O-B-E MOTHERFUCKERS FUCK T-MAC WIT HIS LAZY ASS EYE HAHAHAA...KOBE IS A ALL AROUND PLAYER,T-MAC CAN SCORE WIT NO DEFENSE,HE PASS THE ROCK SOMTIMES
..BUT KOBE BETTER PLAIN AND SIMPLE..HOLLA

aight ok first to what bk said t mac has more tripple doubles than kobe this year last year and the year before so dont say he cant pass...... both of these players are superstars kobe had a streak ogf liek 10 35 or betters ..... t mac has turned the magics franchise around tmac gets more rebounds... and who ever said that tmac shoots less then kobe is wrong tmac takes 65% of his teams shots a game and liek you said that with him not bein in ther ein the 4th quarter you cant not compare these guys against each other goin towards these to and AI are three best players in the league its close but i say there just to close to compare ya know?

Lol, this is easy, Kobe. Easily. Use this year for example. Kobe been scoring 40 a game. T-Mac just started recently. Come on now..

You can even look at the stats on NBA dot com.

Kobe: PPG- 28.4

T-Mac: PPG- 24.0

Statistics never lie. Holla at me.

Oh Yeah, LOL check this out, Labron averages more PPG than Mac, 24.4. Holla at me. Mac not even in the top 5 scorers right now. Even Dwayne Wade infront of him.

yeah mac is not at his full potential this year...the rockets record shows that *shurgs*

Kobe.

if T-mac and Yao would work together i wouldn't give this one to Mac

but T is overall better
Kobe is just a one-man team......but T is the better one man team

again, Kobe is better......and not because of stats...to the kid a lil above, just cuz kobe is scoring more, doesn't prove anything...

but kobe is playing better....even though he's not shooting that great, the team is still playing decent, meanwhile T-Mac and the Rockets are producing anything.....its the biggest disappointment of the season


not to mention, T-Mac and his 19 game losing streak last year.....even the Bobcats are playing better than the Magic did last year when they had T-Mac

oh, and to name some great accomplishments, Kobe had a 11 game, 35 points+ sterak, and 9 games with 40 points+

and as for the career high, T-Mac has that over Kobe....but Kobe could have easily scored 62 points, because, if you remember, Kobe scored 56 points in 3 quarters.......ONLY 3 QUARTERS....if Phil played him in the 4th quarter....the man could have scored 70 points.....it just leaves you sayin "dang, why didn't Phil let em get his chance"


newayz, Kobe is better, but even so, its a neverending discussion

^ just a reminder, bein from o-town and all, and watchin mcgrady score his 63 point game... that was only done in three quarters as well, you can't use if, and what mighta happened when comparing two ball players... but in my honest opinion, I hate both of these guys. If I had to choose, it's Kobe but this debate is so last year, like when this post originally took place... the questions now are like amare stoudamire or kevin garnett? They're puttin up similar numbers this year, the difference? It took Garnett 5 or 6 years outta high school to get his game to the next level, amare? His third season now, and he's already atop the NBA... Now the realist debate of all I can come up with this season, with how it's been goin, is Dwayne Wade or Lebron James

^ just a reminder, bein from o-town and all, and watchin mcgrady score his 63 point game... that was only done in three quarters as well, you can't use if, and what mighta happened when comparing two ball players... but in my honest opinion, I hate both of these guys. If I had to choose, it's Kobe but this debate is so last year, like when this post originally took place... the questions now are like amare stoudamire or kevin garnett? They're puttin up similar numbers this year, the difference? It took Garnett 5 or 6 years outta high school to get his game to the next level, amare? His third season now, and he's already atop the NBA... Now the realist debate of all I can come up with this season, with how it's been goin, is Dwayne Wade or Lebron James



uhhh....NO!!............KG and Amare's numbers are no where near similar and keep in mind that you have to give a lot of credit to Nash for getting Amare those point numbers....Amare has no post finess moves....now, back to numbers where you tried to say they are similar



Amare-26ppg, KG-23ppg....so, Amare has that edge...no doubt....but....

Amare-8rpg, KG-15rpg.....Amare still can't rebound....

Amare-1apg, KG-6apg......KG makes his players better, he passes, Amare doesn't

Amare only dominants as a scorer, and its easy to do it when you got a nice Fastbreak point guard in Nash who can find Amare in the best places.....now, ima fan of Amare....but you can't put him in the same sentence as KG.....maybe KG vs. Tim Duncan, but not KG vs. Amare