View Full Version : BoneStarr vs. Bananaz (iLove)
BoneStarr 07-16-2006, 05:16 PM Freestyle Album Cover
Terms:
Any artist you want, not a mixtape cover though, make it look proffesional, with small details, like retailer, logos etc.... Imagine you was making this for a real record company...
-Voters should remember these terms when voting
Due by:
Whenever really, as long as its this week, lets say before Wednesday, check in to say your up for it
Votes:
Only proper votes count, explaining things well, bad votes won't be counted.
3-0 = K.O.B
5 vote = Win
Check
DooDoo Face!!! 07-16-2006, 09:28 PM hahaha, if i were u id be scared... because u never know what ill come out with!! AHHH! you are scared i KNOW it!! haha im in, ill start if not finish tonight
BoneStarr 07-17-2006, 07:28 AM ^^Just make sure your familiar with the terms, Banana boy, good luck
BoneStarr 07-17-2006, 02:02 PM http://img415.imageshack.us/img415/2055/shroomplaygroundjc3.jpg
My drop
Aesop Rock - Psychedelic Playground
DooDoo Face!!! 07-18-2006, 12:43 AM alright, its not exactly for an artist, but its more a soundtrack type album cover, and after this piece i believe im going to try and stop doing champloo stuff for a while... i thought it came out looking nice, seeing how it went along with the vibe of the series itself...
http://img92.imageshack.us/img92/3977/champloocovercopypw1.jpg
Samurai Champloo - Passion
blending:bone
brushing:bone
creativity:bananza
text:banaza wasnt feeling bones at all
cutting: anime pics arent hard to cut but i think bananza
effort: bone
background: banaza
vote-bananza
i wasnt really feelin bones at all really
the brushing has some really annoying colots lol
i think bananzas is layed out better
and bones gives me a headache if u look at it too long
good battle
really close
DooDoo Face!!! 07-18-2006, 01:32 AM ^thx for the vote
1-0
.Dee. 07-18-2006, 09:41 AM blending: Bone (Banz was only drop shadow)
brushing: Bone
creativity:Banz (Ive hanvent seen anything like it)
text: Banz (because Bones doesnt fit at all)
cutting: Tie
effort: Bone
background: Bone (it was more colorful, and I thought it looked dope)
vote-Bones
Banz had a good drop but the BG was like hihgly unoticeable
do to how big the stock was, I was likes Bonez because his
BG was nice, dope, and shiney which easily caught my eye.
Nice Drop
It was close.
Gusto 07-18-2006, 09:53 AM blending: Bonestarr.......render faded into BG flawlessly
brushing: Bonestarr......by a long shot
creativity:Bonestarr, Bananaz looks like a bunch of stuff thrown together
text: Bonstarr, I didnt like the glow on Bananaz
cutting:N/A
effort: Bonestarr
background: Bonestarr, it was all brushing, but so was bannanas and bonestarr won the brushing cat so this automaticly goes to him
(if bananaz isnt all brushing too, sorry but if you picked that bg premade...I would say you lost this cat even more)
Vote bonestarr
coolplaya 07-18-2006, 12:08 PM Okkkkk...
Blending: I think Bonestarr had some basic blending(brush over render) which in this case seemed to work. I think Bananaz blending was more as similar colors of the render and background, which also works.
Brushing: Well I'm not sure if Bananaz used brushing or the pen tool for the shapes, but I'm guessing the pentool so he didn't do much brushing. Bonestarr had some pretty nice brushing, got a little repetitive seeing the same thing everywhere though.
Creativity: Bonestarr was pretty creative making the background psychadelic. Both were different types of styles though, but I liked Bananaz vector work which looked pretty creative.
Text: Bananaz looked a bit too plain for a OST. I would expect something a bit more. Bonestarr's looked pretty average. Both text's could use a bit more work.
Effort: Both covers looked pretty hard worked on. I found Bananaz looked a bit rushed especially on the render work.
Background: Apparently Murderous doesn't know a bg is all about brushes. I haven't seen many vector backgrounds on this site so that's what made it stand out much more, and it is also very nicely done. Bonestarr's background fits the "psycadelic" theme very well.
Overall: My overall vote goes to Bananaz/iLove mainly because it was more original, and personal preferance. Good battle.
BoneStarr 07-18-2006, 12:16 PM blending:bone
brushing:bone
creativity:bananza
text:banaza wasnt feeling bones at all
cutting: anime pics arent hard to cut but i think bananza
effort: bone
background: banaza
vote-bananza
i wasnt really feelin bones at all really
the brushing has some really annoying colots lol
i think bananzas is layed out better
and bones gives me a headache if u look at it too long
good battle
really close
LOL, thats the idea, if you have ever tried magic mushrooms you would really understand the nature of this peice, the kids paranoid because he can't get the colours out of his head, or stoping himself from seeing them... Im glad you said this, it means that I got the effect right on the BG :cool:
2-2 uppin for more votes
Im gonna try and rep all who have voted till now, Bnanaz, you should do the same, its hard finding voters nowadays... :(
DooDoo Face!!! 07-18-2006, 04:07 PM ^hahahahah, alright! btw, about the whole brushing/bg shit on my piece, i did do the bg all with vector brushes... cooool
2-2 good battle so far
lmao
it wasnt bad
but it was just like GOD DAMN MAN
and i do not trip on the shrooms so i couldnt help u there man
good work from both tho
even tho they not to my liking
just not my style
BoneStarr 07-19-2006, 09:18 AM lmao
it wasnt bad
but it was just like GOD DAMN MAN
and i do not trip on the shrooms so i couldnt help u there man
good work from both tho
even tho they not to my liking
just not my style
Well you can't make pop out cd covers mate... 8-)
^^ LOL
Design: Bone (I like it more, just looks nice, and goes well)
Effort: Tie (Both seem to have a lot of effort put in, and alot of thinking went into both)
Creativity: Bone (I personally think theres alot more creativity in it)
Text: Bone (Bananaz was WAY too simple, i like bones i think it fits, although the positioning of the title is wierd, but the artist name position is perfect)
Blending: Bananaz (I think you blended yours better)
Image Cutting: Tie (your cutting was good, and both seem to be perfect)
Brushing: Bone (Yours works real well, and goes well with the theme of the album, i liked Bananaz but your was slightly better IMO)
Background: Bananaz (BG looks dope from what i can see of it)
Vote: Bonestarr
Both did very unique and good album designs but i like and think Bones is better, very close battle but Bones took this one for me. GJ guys.
.majiK™ 07-19-2006, 02:42 PM Design: iLove
Effort: Tie
Creativity: Tie
Text: Bonestarr
Blending: Bananaz
Image Cutting: Tie
Brushing: Bonestarr
Background: Bananaz
iLove - Text was too simple and I didnt like the "Samuel Champloo" text, other than that it was dope.
Bone - I liked the brushing alot but I think the whole thing would of worked alot better on a sig, it just didnt seem right to me on an album cover. I liked the theme you had going with the kid and everythiing though.
Vote: Bananaz aka iLove
DooDoo Face!!! 07-19-2006, 06:52 PM ^^^LMAO at bonestarrs comment at rambo... hahahaha, very true.. hahaha
3-3 very good battle, will it ever be finished?? haha
Not Jewish 07-20-2006, 07:52 AM Design: Bonestarr, i just liked it better
Effort: Bananaz
Creativity: Bonestarr, i liked the way he did it all together
Text: Bonestarr, just like it better
Blending: Bananaz, was better imo
Image Cutting: both
Brushing: Bonestarr, jus the fact that it went more with the theme as azim said
Background: Bananaz, looking good
Vote: Bonestarr
BoneStarr 07-20-2006, 08:47 AM Damn this battle is close.... 4 - 3
Not Jewish 07-20-2006, 09:31 AM lmfao @ bonestarr & sc rambo lol
Speak. 07-20-2006, 09:21 PM Design: banny's looked more like a drawing style thing, and bonestarr's had more of an aim into it, so bonestarr
Effort: tie
Creativity: tie
Text: bonestarr was slightly ahead on this
Blending: bone's was ok, but banny matched the bg with the renders a lil bit better
Image Cutting: tie
Brushing: bonestarr
Background:boney, it just makes me think more
overall vote- bonestarr took this in my eyes, but best 'other' style gfx battle i ever seen, what is it now 5-4
Clusion 07-21-2006, 03:40 AM I didnt like both pieces, i realy feel these are not really album covers, you should have both gone with something more simple. But...
Design: Bone
Creativity: None
Text: Bone
Blending: Meh, None
Brushing: Bone
Background:Bone (but never put the drop shadow on something so flat.)
Vote: Bone
6-4
|
|