View Full Version : BoneStarr vs. CoolPlayer (sprite battle)


BoneStarr
07-23-2006, 08:27 PM
Sprite sig battle

Terms:
Sig with sprite image in it, any size you like, no Sc Rambo (no pop out :D), just a sig, plain and simple...
You must drope 2 links for the battle

-Voters should remember these terms when voting

Due by:
Wednesday, any time of the day if you finish the sig before wednesday don't post it, wait till wednesday...

Votes:
Only proper votes count, explaining things well, bad votes won't be counted.


3-0 = K.O.B
5 vote = Win

Check

coolplaya
07-23-2006, 08:28 PM
Sounds good.. check...

coolplaya
07-25-2006, 08:23 PM
http://img230.imageshack.us/img230/8637/codysprite2ss5.jpg

Good Luck :)

BoneStarr
07-25-2006, 08:25 PM
http://www.rapworlds.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74371

http://www.rapworlds.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75541

^^My links

http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/2883/ryuvsakumatu4.jpg

^^My drop

Good Luck!

coolplaya
07-25-2006, 08:54 PM
You only need 1 link I think...

http://www.rapworlds.com/forums/showthread.php?p=938682#post938682

Hehe.. Btw.. No C4D for me :)

Upping.

Esinem
07-26-2006, 11:21 AM
Coolplayer: I liked your piece because it was very creative, and I liked the look on it. Quite original in many ways. I like how the blue coming from the right fades a little then turns into brown. Very well blended. Render is good, and the text is above average. The only thing that throws it off is the light blue rectangle on the right side (some-what of a border)

Bonestarr: Liked the renders and background you used. I think your C4D is too bright, and it`s hard to see Ryu. But none the less it`s still quite good. I don`t quite like the 3 exact motion blurred whatevers (if you look under the dragon (infront of the chinese lettering, there will be 3 motion blurred figures the exact same).

Text - Bonestarr (Even tho t`s basically alike, I just feel as if Bonestarrs` text stood out more.)
Blending - Bonestarr (I just think BS Blended it in a bit better)
Creativity - Coolplayer (I just think his was more creative and more original)
Render - Well, both were good. But Bonestarr had 2.. and they were both good, and 2 is always better then one. so, Bonestarr.
Border - Bonestarr (Coolplayers` is good, but that blue border-tye thing on the right lost it)
Effort - Coolplayer (just seems liek he started from scratch and made everything himself or the majority. Just looks like BS threwon some renders, C4D and text over a background and motion blurred some things)

Vote - Bonestarr. I just feel as if he did better then Coolplayer, even tho coolplayer wasn`t that far behind him.

Good shit guys. Props to both of you.

BoneStarr
07-26-2006, 10:35 PM
1-0 Uppin for more votes peeps...

Gusto
07-27-2006, 10:46 AM
Text -Coolplayer
Blending - Bonestarr
Creativity -tie
Render - Bonestarr
Border - Bonestarr
Effort -.....I honestly cant tell you who put more effort in there sig, they both look good


Coolplayers was nice, but I honestly like that Bonestarr threw in the neon sign and had the action going on, with the uppercut, where as coolplayer had the guy kicking and stuff, but I think bonestarrs was better for a overall feel of "somthing going on" Im not a big fan of this type of ps art but these are pretty good.
Vote is gonna be Bonestarr


I think the border hurt Coolplayer alot
But he had better text IMO
both renders where decent, but I have seen better.

Good battle you two.

coolplaya
07-27-2006, 10:50 AM
Thanks for voting ^^^^

2-0 Bonestarr. Uppin.

Mafioso
07-27-2006, 06:39 PM
Coolplayer: I liked your piece because it was very creative, and I liked the look on it. Quite original in many ways. I like how the blue coming from the right fades a little then turns into brown. Very well blended. Render is good, and the text is above average. The only thing that throws it off is the light blue rectangle on the right side (some-what of a border)

Bonestarr: Liked the renders and background you used. I think your C4D is too bright, and it`s hard to see Ryu. But none the less it`s still quite good. I don`t quite like the 3 exact motion blurred whatevers (if you look under the dragon (infront of the chinese lettering, there will be 3 motion blurred figures the exact same).

Text - Bonestarr (Even tho t`s basically alike, I just feel as if Bonestarrs` text stood out more.)
Blending - Bonestarr (I just think BS Blended it in a bit better)
Creativity - Coolplayer (I just think his was more creative and more original)
Render - Well, both were good. But Bonestarr had 2.. and they were both good, and 2 is always better then one. so, Bonestarr.
Border - Bonestarr
Effort - Coolplayer (just seems liek he started from scratch and made everything himself or the majority. Just looks like BS threwon some renders, C4D and text over a background and motion blurred some things)

Vote - Bonestarr.


MY VOTE-BS

BoneStarr
07-27-2006, 07:02 PM
3-0 But I dunno if this vote can count, you need to give a detailed explanaition of your own Shadow, so unles you do so, this vote don't really count... :(

Mafioso
07-27-2006, 10:18 PM
ok will do...

in a minute cuz i gotta get some popcorn

Gusto
07-28-2006, 05:36 AM
^^ awww......:)

BoneStarr
07-29-2006, 06:10 AM
Cmon guys vote up...

Nems
07-29-2006, 03:41 PM
i like both pieces..

cool-
coolplayers looked a bit plain though...but the colors blended in well..i didn't like the render out line fill in thing..behind the render.. still was a good sig

Bone-
bonestars..was tight..the lightting was coo..the whole b/g was tight and ryo and akuma were placed well..the text could of used some work but overall you could hardly notice...

Text -Coolplayer
Blending - Bonestarr
Creativity -tie
Render - Bonestarr
Border - Bonestarr
v/-Bonestarr

BoneStarr
07-30-2006, 02:33 AM
Not counting shadow's vote that is a 3-0 K.O.B thread closed...

ramb
07-30-2006, 02:37 AM
good job bone please vote on my battle against murder

E-Clipse
07-30-2006, 06:27 PM
Text - Tie
Blending - B
Creativity - C
Render - B
Border - B
Effort - Tie

Overall- BoneStarr

BoneStarr
07-31-2006, 08:39 PM
Ok thats 4-0 now, this can be closed by a MOD